Comics Bulletin logo
Search
  • Columns
    Random
    • All The Rage: Talking With Joe Illidge About DC Comics

      Chase Magnett
      October 9, 2000
      All the Rage
    Recent
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 2

      Daniel Gehen
      December 4, 2020
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 1

      Daniel Gehen
      October 30, 2020
    • Comictober 2020: DRACULA MOTHERF**KER

      Daniel Gehen
      October 27, 2020
    • What Looks Good
    • Comics Bulletin Soapbox
    • The Full Run
    • Leading Question
    • Top 10
    • The Long-Form
    • Jumping On
    • Comics in Color
    • Slouches Towards Comics
  • Big Two
    Random
    • 5.0

      Review: FAR SECTOR #6 is the Green Lantern Comic We Need

      Chase Magnett
      June 4, 2020
      Big Two, Big Two Reviews, DC Comics, Reviews
    Recent
    • Retro Review: Detective Comics #826 Remains a Holiday Classic

      Daniel Gehen
      December 3, 2020
    • Stan Lee

      nguyen ly
      November 7, 2020
    • Collecting Profile: Jack O’ Lantern

      nguyen ly
      October 31, 2020
    • DC Comics
    • Big Two Reviews
    • Marvel Comics
  • Indie
    Random
    • Interview: Nicole Goux and Dave Baker Commit to "Murders"

      Chase Magnett
      March 27, 2017
      Indie, Interviews, Small Press
    Recent
    • Review: The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Cartoonist

      Daniel Gehen
      December 14, 2020
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 2

      Daniel Gehen
      December 4, 2020
    • 4.5

      TMNT: The Last Ronin #1 Lives Up to the Hype (Review)

      Daniel Gehen
      October 29, 2020
    • Reviews
    • Archie Comics
    • Boom! Studios
    • Dark Horse
    • IDW
    • Image
    • Oni Press
    • Valiant
  • Reviews
    Random
    • 3.0

      Vampirella #4

      Chase Magnett
      March 19, 2011
      Reviews
    Recent
    • Review: The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Cartoonist

      Daniel Gehen
      December 14, 2020
    • Retro Review: Detective Comics #826 Remains a Holiday Classic

      Daniel Gehen
      December 3, 2020
    • 4.5

      TMNT: The Last Ronin #1 Lives Up to the Hype (Review)

      Daniel Gehen
      October 29, 2020
    • Singles Going Steady
    • Slugfest
    • Manga
      • Reviews
    • Small Press
      • Reviews
      • ICYMI
      • Tiny Pages Made of Ashes
  • Interviews
    Random
    • Ed Brisson: Crime Meets Time Travel with Comeback

      Chase Magnett
      December 18, 2012
      Interviews
    Recent
    • Interview: Jon Davis-Hunt Talks SHADOWMAN

      Daniel Gehen
      June 8, 2020
    • Interview: Becky Cloonan talks DARK AGNES and Her Personal Influences

      Mike Nickells
      March 4, 2020
    • Simon Roy

      Interview: Simon Roy on His Inspirations and Collaborations on PROTECTOR

      Mike Nickells
      January 29, 2020
    • Audio Interview
    • Video Interview
  • Classic Comics
    Random
    • DC Showcase Presents Bat Lash

      Chase Magnett
      May 22, 2012
      Classic Comics Cavalcade, Columns
    Recent
    • Countdown to the King: Marvel’s Godzilla

      Daniel Gehen
      May 29, 2019
    • Honoring A Legend: Fantagraphics To Resurrect Tomi Ungerer Classics

      Daniel Gehen
      February 15, 2019
    • Reliving the Craziest Decade in Comics History: An interview with Jason Sacks

      Mark Stack
      January 2, 2019
    • Classic Comics Cavalcade
    • Classic Interviews
  • News
    Random
    • A Full Replay of NCSFest 2020 is now Available

      Chase Magnett
      September 15, 2020
      News
    Recent
    • 2020 Ringo Awards Winners Announced

      Daniel Gehen
      October 26, 2020
    • BAD IDEA Announces 2021 Publishing Slate

      Daniel Gehen
      September 29, 2020
    • A Full Replay of NCSFest 2020 is now Available

      Daniel Gehen
      September 15, 2020
    • Press Release
    • Kickstarter Spotlight
  • Books
    Random
    • Pénélope Bagieu is California Dreamin'

      Chase Magnett
      July 18, 2017
      Books
    Recent
    • Collecting Profile: Disney Frozen

      CB Staff
      November 22, 2019
    • Collecting Profile: NFL Superpro

      CB Staff
      August 31, 2019
    • “THE BEST OF WITZEND” is a Wonderful Celebration of Artistic Freedom

      Daniel Gehen
      September 15, 2018
    • Review: ‘Machete Squad’ is a Disappointing Afghan Memoir

      Jason Sacks
      July 31, 2018
    • Review: ‘Out of Nothing’ is the Antidote to Our Sick Times

      Jason Sacks
      July 23, 2018
    • Review: ‘Bizarre Romance’ Shows Rough Edges in the Early Days of a New Marriage

      Jason Sacks
      July 10, 2018
What's New
  • Collecting Profile: Batwoman
  • Collecting Profile: Daredevil
  • Collecting Profile: Floronic Man
  • Review of Cheetah in Wonder Woman 1984
  • Review: The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Cartoonist
  • Collecting Profile: Transformers
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Contact Us
  • Write for us!
  • Visit Video Game Break!
Home
Columns

Cyclops #5 and The Perils of Devotion

Chase Magnett
September 30, 2014
Columns, Comics Bulletin Soapbox

I want to be very clear going into this critique: I am providing a critical analysis of a single issue of a comic book. I am also critiquing the community that reviewed a comic book. That is it. This is not a declaration of outrage. This is not an attack on any creators. This is not fan fury. It is an attempt at an informed analysis of a comic book.

I’ve been regularly enjoying the first four issues of the new Marvel series Cyclops. Greg Rucka has written a father-son tale that balances humor and pathos inside the genre trappings of a space opera. Artist Russell Dauterman has evoked a wide variety of alien landscapes, flora, and fauna, making the comic a visual treat. This is all very good.

But the most recent issue, Cyclops #5, presents a deeply troubling scenario.

Cyclops #5 centers around a conflict between Cyclops, his father Corsair, and a group of bounty hunters. The hunters are led by Travis. Travis is a slave holder. The word ‘slave’ is never used in the comic, but the story makes that relationship clear. The first sequence of the issue introduces Travis and Savva. Savva is shown serving Travis: she kneels before him and only calls him “Master”. When she begs Travis to eat something, he grabs her by the throat and dismisses her. His actions towards her are consistently dominant and cruel in nature. There is no doubt that Travis and Savva are master and slave.

Cyclops 5 - 1

There are some allusions to this being a master/slave relationship in the script as well. Savva does not appear to be a proper name, but a title. Travis calls her “my Savva” and she refers to herself as “the Savva”. Cyclops even explains to Corsair that, “Travis is her master, she is indentured to him.” The history of indentured labor does not separate that term from the concept of slavery. They have often been one and the same thing.

It’s not the existence of slavery in the story that is troublesome, though. It is the manner in which the heroes handle its existence. At the end of the issue, Savva makes an arrangement with Cyclops to save Travis, but in order to save his life, she must betray him. Cyclops and Corsair are able to make their escape, but they leave Savva with Travis. It is heavily implied that Savva will be physically reprimanded for her actions. Cyclops says, “Travis is gonna punish her,” and Travis’ earlier abuse with minimal provocation does not bode well for Savva’s well being.

Cyclops 5 - 2

Cyclops is rightly disturbed at this outcome and questions his father about it. Rather than address whether it is morally conscionable to abandon a slave (even one who does not want to leave) to the abuse of his or her master, Corsair tells Cyclops that what Savva has done is ‘honorable’. He places the value of keeping a promise above the horrors of slavery.

That’s a big problem.

The conceit here, the moral about honor and promise keeping, dodges the ethical issues at play and undermines the deeper issues. The conclusion to this issue is either ignorant of these problems or too lazy to address them. They are certainly present throughout. Slavery and physical abuse exist within the context of the story, and they are summarily dismissed by the heroes of the story.

Cyclops and Corsair are witness to a situation that involves both slavery and physical abuse. It is further complicated by the fact that the victim of both has seemingly become a willing participant. No one will deny that this is an incredibly complicated moral scenario. However, choosing to construct such a nuanced situation means creators ought to be prepared to address its consequences. The characters’ choice to tolerate what has already happened and will continue to happen is morally troubling, especially for a hero like Cyclops. To explain that choice with a quip about ‘honor’ is lazy and does not lend these issues the weight they demand.

Cyclops 5 - 3

Cyclops #5 does not actively endorse slavery, but it allows that people can choose to be made slaves. It does not actively endorse domestic abuse, but it allows that victims should be allowed to remain in potentially lethal relationships. Both of these allowances are big problems.

We should not judge the character of Greg Rucka or penciller Carmen Carnero based on this lone sequence. Their work elsewhere in comics and in life show them to be outstanding creators and individuals. However, read only within its own context, Cyclops #5 presents these ideas and subtle endorsements which are seemingly in direct conflict with Cyclops’ own initial heroic instincts. It’s a failure of the larger story and one for which Rucka and Carnero should be held accountable.

It’s also one that seems to have been entirely ignored. Of the reviews published concerning Cyclops #5, none address the topic of slavery. Only one mentions the word “indentured”, but does not follow up on the implications of this relationship or the heroes’ decision not to intervene on Savva’s behalf. Critics writing about this issue are either not engaging with the text or are purposefully ignoring these issues.

The presence of slavery in Cyclops #5 is clear. Engaging with the dialogue and images reveals a great deal of evidence that Savva is both a slave and victim of domestic abuse that Corsair and Cyclops chose not to rescue. This is not a theory or extrapolation, it is a clear conclusion based upon the text. For reviewers to have either missed this element of the story or chosen to ignore it is a major oversight. It is the role and responsibility of critics to actively engage with a work of art – in this case, a comic book – to understand and explore it. In doing so, they can assist others in deriving greater value from the art. Missing deeply troubling elements like this reveals a culture of critics who are not yet up to that task.

Rucka and Carnero are adults and professionals. They are capable of handling criticism. They have both created excellent comics before and I have no doubt that they will do so again. Comics is a small community and those of us who write about comics often know or know of the creators we write about. I interviewed Rucka this spring for almost an hour and was deeply impressed by him as a writer and human being. But it’s dishonest for me as a critic to ignore a problem in his work out of fear that I may offend him.

What I find most troubling about this issue is not the lazy dismissal of slavery and abuse, but the unwillingness of comics reviewers and critics to engage with the material. It’s not that all writers should have noticed this or chosen to write about it, but every individual who wrote about Cyclops #5 either ignored or missed the topic.

Rucka, Carnero, and their readers deserve better critics.

Carmen CarneroCriticismCyclopsGreg RuckaMarvel ComicsSlavery

Share On:
Tweet
Planetary #3: No One Understands Life Better Than A Betrayed Cop Executed in Hong Kong
Singles Going Steady 9/30/2014: Butterflies, Dragons and Other Flying Nuisances

About The Author

Chase Magnett
Comics Theorist

Chase is a mild-mannered finance guy by day and a raving comics fan by night. He has been reading comics for more than half of his life. After graduating from the University of Nebraska–Lincoln with degrees in Economics and English, he has continued to research comics while writing articles and reviews online. His favorite superhero is Superman and he'll accept no other answers. Don't ask about his favorite comic unless you're ready to spend a day discussing dozens of different titles.

Related Posts

  • 4.5

    Review: X-MEN #1 – The Good Times are Here

    Jason Jeffords Jr.
    October 17, 2019
  • House of X #5: Death and Resurrection Is The Latest Fashion

    Jason Jeffords Jr.
    September 19, 2019

Latest Columns

  • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 2

    Daniel Gehen
    December 4, 2020
  • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 1

    Daniel Gehen
    October 30, 2020
  • Comictober 2020: DRACULA MOTHERF**KER

    Daniel Gehen
    October 27, 2020
  • What Looks Good for the Week of 10/14/2020

    Daniel Gehen
    October 12, 2020
  • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – Monster Mash!

    Daniel Gehen
    October 9, 2020
RSSTwitterFacebookgoogleplusinstagramtumblr

Comics Bulletin is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, audible.com, and any other website that may be affiliated with Amazon Service LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, Comics Bulletin earns from qualifying purchases.

All content on this site (c) 2018 The Respective Copyright Holders