Writer: Joe Kelly
Artists: Doug Mahnke (p), Tom Nguyen (i)
On an alien world that is being invaded by a race who claim they are acting to advance galactic peace, we see the JLA find themselves in a situation where choosing either side in this conflict is not exactly the ideal solution to this crisis.
It is a little creepy to see the drama playing out in the pages of this comic mirroring real world events so closely, and to a certain extent it does make the catch 22 dilemma that the JLA get themselves ensnared in more dramatic, as one can't help but draw parallels. Now this being a comic Joe Kelly doesn't exactly go too deep, as the situation is a pretty bare bones affair, but there was enough on the page that I was rather impressed by the material. However, this is also the issue where I officially no longer want Faith as a member of the JLA, as this issue clearly establishes her as the character that Joe Kelly will drag out when he's painted the team into a corner, and her big display of power will instantly solve the crisis at hand. I don't like characters who exist solely to make a writer's job easily, especially when it comes to the final climax.
Now I realize that this is the JLA, and as such we're operating on a whole different power level, but from a storytelling sense Faith's ability does not make for a rewarding finish. As for the art, Doug Mahnke continues to display his ability to deliver the big level action that is a key component of this series, as the assault by the alien armada is a visually impressive sequence. It would've been nice to get a better look at what exactly Faith had managed to accomplish with her counterattack though.
An interesting dilemma that is completely underdone by a highly simplistic finish where Joe Kelly essentially offers up one of my least favorite endings that any writer can tack on to their story. I mean having Faith essentially defeat the entire alien armada in a single page is the modern day equivalent of the classic Silver Age ending where the entire story was revealed to be a dream. This type of ending doesn't require any real creative thought on Joe Kelly's behalf, and as long as Faith is a member of the team I'm going to be left with the idea that when things get too tough he'll have a nice handy easy out that he can use to resolve the conflict. The basic theme of this issue was pretty solid though, and up until Faith's little display of power I was ready to give this book a glowing review for its presentation of a rather atypical JLA scenario. In the end though this is an issue that is undone by its weak conflict resolution.
What did you think of this book?
Have your say at the Line of Fire Forum!