Current Reviews


Outsiders #1

Posted: Tuesday, July 8, 2003
By: Page45

Writer: Judd Winnick
Artist: Tom Raney

Publisher: DC

Donna Troi is dead, and Nightwing is so cut up about it that he refuses to lead another superteam for half a dozen pages. You really have to be trying to be this formulaic; you can't stumble upon this many clichés without concentrating.

Raney's art isn't as consistently grotesque as his STORMWATCH era (this is a compliment), and I quite liked the exchange between a resurrected Metamorpho with a degree of amnesia, and a chap I assume to have been Green Arrow's old Speedy: "I thought I told you to wait outside." "Emergency. I had to pee." "I wasn't aware you could do that." "Me either. Hence the emergency."

But the man who gave us PEDRO & ME and the ADVENTURES OF BARRY WEEN really should get out of the superhero game and return to what he does best, which is anything other than this.

Visit Page45 Online

What did you think of this book?
Have your say at the Line of Fire Forum!