Comics Bulletin logo
Search
  • Columns
    Random
    • Kids vs. Robots: The Sweet Art of FF

      Daniel Gehen
      March 14, 2012
      Columns
    Recent
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 2

      Daniel Gehen
      December 4, 2020
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 1

      Daniel Gehen
      October 30, 2020
    • Comictober 2020: DRACULA MOTHERF**KER

      Daniel Gehen
      October 27, 2020
    • What Looks Good
    • Comics Bulletin Soapbox
    • The Full Run
    • Leading Question
    • Top 10
    • The Long-Form
    • Jumping On
    • Comics in Color
    • Slouches Towards Comics
  • Big Two
    Random
    • Collecting Profile: Cheetah (DC Comics)

      Daniel Gehen
      May 11, 2019
      Big Two, Collectibles, DC Comics, Miscellaneous Comic Book Content
    Recent
    • Retro Review: Detective Comics #826 Remains a Holiday Classic

      Daniel Gehen
      December 3, 2020
    • Stan Lee

      nguyen ly
      November 7, 2020
    • Collecting Profile: Jack O’ Lantern

      nguyen ly
      October 31, 2020
    • DC Comics
    • Big Two Reviews
    • Marvel Comics
  • Indie
    Random
    • Countdown to the King: Godzilla In Hell

      Daniel Gehen
      May 22, 2019
      Columns, IDW
    Recent
    • Review: The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Cartoonist

      Daniel Gehen
      December 14, 2020
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 2

      Daniel Gehen
      December 4, 2020
    • 4.5

      TMNT: The Last Ronin #1 Lives Up to the Hype (Review)

      Daniel Gehen
      October 29, 2020
    • Reviews
    • Archie Comics
    • Boom! Studios
    • Dark Horse
    • IDW
    • Image
    • Oni Press
    • Valiant
  • Reviews
    Random
    • 4.5

      The Fades 1.06 Review

      Daniel Gehen
      February 19, 2012
      Reviews
    Recent
    • Review: The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Cartoonist

      Daniel Gehen
      December 14, 2020
    • Retro Review: Detective Comics #826 Remains a Holiday Classic

      Daniel Gehen
      December 3, 2020
    • 4.5

      TMNT: The Last Ronin #1 Lives Up to the Hype (Review)

      Daniel Gehen
      October 29, 2020
    • Singles Going Steady
    • Slugfest
    • Manga
      • Reviews
    • Small Press
      • Reviews
      • ICYMI
      • Tiny Pages Made of Ashes
  • Interviews
    Random
    • Western Misadventures with Writer Jay Carvajal

      Daniel Gehen
      September 14, 2007
      Interviews
    Recent
    • Interview: Jon Davis-Hunt Talks SHADOWMAN

      Daniel Gehen
      June 8, 2020
    • Interview: Becky Cloonan talks DARK AGNES and Her Personal Influences

      Mike Nickells
      March 4, 2020
    • Simon Roy

      Interview: Simon Roy on His Inspirations and Collaborations on PROTECTOR

      Mike Nickells
      January 29, 2020
    • Audio Interview
    • Video Interview
  • Classic Comics
    Random
    • Small-Press Super-Heroes of the '80s: Nexus

      Daniel Gehen
      October 24, 2014
      Classic Comics Cavalcade, Columns
    Recent
    • Countdown to the King: Marvel’s Godzilla

      Daniel Gehen
      May 29, 2019
    • Honoring A Legend: Fantagraphics To Resurrect Tomi Ungerer Classics

      Daniel Gehen
      February 15, 2019
    • Reliving the Craziest Decade in Comics History: An interview with Jason Sacks

      Mark Stack
      January 2, 2019
    • Classic Comics Cavalcade
    • Classic Interviews
  • News
    Random
    • Bizarre New World: "Sky Patrol"

      Daniel Gehen
      May 3, 2015
      News, Previews
    Recent
    • 2020 Ringo Awards Winners Announced

      Daniel Gehen
      October 26, 2020
    • BAD IDEA Announces 2021 Publishing Slate

      Daniel Gehen
      September 29, 2020
    • A Full Replay of NCSFest 2020 is now Available

      Daniel Gehen
      September 15, 2020
    • Press Release
    • Kickstarter Spotlight
  • Books
    Random
    • Pénélope Bagieu is California Dreamin'

      Daniel Gehen
      July 18, 2017
      Books
    Recent
    • Collecting Profile: Disney Frozen

      CB Staff
      November 22, 2019
    • Collecting Profile: NFL Superpro

      CB Staff
      August 31, 2019
    • “THE BEST OF WITZEND” is a Wonderful Celebration of Artistic Freedom

      Daniel Gehen
      September 15, 2018
    • Review: ‘Machete Squad’ is a Disappointing Afghan Memoir

      Jason Sacks
      July 31, 2018
    • Review: ‘Out of Nothing’ is the Antidote to Our Sick Times

      Jason Sacks
      July 23, 2018
    • Review: ‘Bizarre Romance’ Shows Rough Edges in the Early Days of a New Marriage

      Jason Sacks
      July 10, 2018
What's New
  • Collecting Profile: Batwoman
  • Collecting Profile: Daredevil
  • Collecting Profile: Floronic Man
  • Review of Cheetah in Wonder Woman 1984
  • Review: The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Cartoonist
  • Collecting Profile: Transformers
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Contact Us
  • Write for us!
  • Visit Video Game Break!
Home
Big Two
Big Two Reviews

SUPERMAN: YEAR ONE #1 is Painfully Mediocre

Daniel Gehen
June 19, 2019
Big Two Reviews, DC Comics, Reviews

DC Comics

(w) Frank Miller (a) John Romita Jr. (i) Danny Miki (c) Alex Sinclair

 Since its initial announcement, readers have braced themselves for the release of Superman: Year One. Many expected a complete train wreck, while others were optimistic that it would see a return to glory for writer Frank Miller. Joined by now-polarizing artist and collaborator on the lauded Daredevil: The Man Without Fear, John Romita Jr, Miller’s approach to Superman gives him yet another updated origin in an effort to better fit the reality of today. To that end, Miller and Romita are successful. But Superman: Year One also defies expectations in that is neither great, nor terrible. Instead, is arguably worse by being completely and utterly forgettable.

The origin of Superman has been told many times. It has been told with remarkable brevity, such as in 1938’s Action Comics #1 or 2004’s All Star Superman #1. It has been told over the course of several issues, such as in 1986’s Man of Steel, 2003’s Superman: Birthright, and 2009’s Superman: Secret Origin. Each was designed to be the definitive origin for the character, the exception being All Star Superman, which ironically is considered by many to be the definitive Superman tale. Also, don’t forget the Earth One line of books, movies, and television shows featuring his origin story. With each new telling of Superman’s beginnings, it renders the previous ones non-canonical. So it begs the question why do readers need another non-canonical origin story? The answer is they don’t.

Image result for superman year one

The “Year One” branding holds a special place in the DC lexicon, alongside “Rebirth,” “Crisis,” and “Secret Origin.” Notable stories with that moniker include Batman: Year One (by Miller), JLA: Year One, and most recently Wonder Woman: Year One. These stories have two major things in common. First, they’re all great. Secondly, they take “year one” seriously and take place over the course of a single year. Superman: Year One fails at meeting either one of those, mostly because Superman’s origin story does not take place over the course of a year, but several years. It’s a story that would be better served under the “Secret Origin” moniker, like Geoff Johns did with Green Lantern and… Superman.

The series’ first issue starts off predictably with the destruction of Krypton. Miller and Romita do change things up slightly, presenting the moments leading up to the planet’s destruction through the eyes of the infant Kal-El. There are explosions and chaos as his parents rush him into the rocket that will bring the child to Earth. Throughout this sequence, narration boxes needlessly describe Romita’s art, which on its own is sufficient. It is done seemingly to convince readers that Miller’s writing will not be full of the bitterness seen in his later Dark Knight books or Holy Terror. However, its very nature begs the question who is narrating? It is clearly written in first person, so is it baby Kal-El? He’s an infant and can barely do anything beyond shit in his diaper, let alone form complete thoughts. Maybe it is him, recounting these memories? But if this is the case, there is nothing to indicate that is so. It is lazy, and that’s how most of Superman: Year One reads.

Image result for superman year one

The narration is arguably the biggest detriment to the story, jumping all over the place and constantly bringing the reader out of the narrative. But aside from that, the story is… fine? There are a couple tweaks to the classic origin, with Jonathan Kent finding the rocket on his own and bringing baby Kal-El/Clark home to Martha. But aside from that, the story is familiar. Clark goes to school and is picked on by bullies, only now he has friends – other social outcasts – which he feels a duty to protect. He is conflicted, and frequently seeks guidance from his adoptive father. This version of Jonathan Kent is not the disgrace seen in the movie Man of Steel, but he still falls short of the standard set by more beloved versions. He’s a bit rough around the edges and protective. However, he at his heart has a kind soul and comes across as man trying to instill in Clark the values that would shape Superman iconography. Miller at least attempts to do something with him, unlike Martha Kent, who may as well not exist. Her virtual absence from the story is noticeable, but given Miller’s propensity for objectifying women, this is probably for the best.

Clark’s supporting cast is comprised of his aforementioned friends, a group of bullies, and his high-school sweetheart Lana Lang. The dialogue is what one would expect from an out-of-touch man in his 60s trying to emulate teenagers. The bullies feel ripped from a classic high school movie, with just a touch of Rob Zombie trashiness for good measure. In one particular scene, Miller almost crosses a certain line which readers expected in some form. Yet, he shows remarkable restraint and instead turns it into a heroic moment for Clark. Still, it does reduce Lana into a helpless object used to drive the Clark’s narrative forward. But beyond this, there are a few genuine bright spots, particularly the relationship between Clark and Lana. Their interactions have an emotional authenticity that frankly has been missing from Miller’s work for a couple of decades. It’s a shame that the story has to move forward to the controversial Navy SEAL phase of Clark’s journey, as his relationship with Lana is worthy of its own story.

Image result for superman year one

Smallville itself is a romanticized version of smalltown America. It appears innocent, and even charmingly unaware – if that is such a thing – of bigger issues. However, the town’s structural problems with injustice are evident as assumed authority figures turn a blind eye to violence perpetuated by local bullies. Their attacks on Clark’s classmates escalate with zero accountability, emboldened in those in power turning a blind eye. Where Miller’s politics lay today is anyone’s guess, but a case could be made for Miller to be commenting on how hate and intolerance are without checks in today’s society.

The artwork from John Romita Jr. is serviceable. It could be better, but it is far from the worst thing he’s produced. His style is best suited for street-level, urban crime stories and that just isn’t what this is. But overall, the compositions are well put together (aside from Clark’s bobblehead), and Danny Miki’s inks try their best to keep the lines clean and the panels detailed. Artistically, the book is carried by Alex Sinclair colors. His use of warm earth tones gives Smallville the classic small town, American midwestern aesthetic that it deserves.

Superman: Year One has its fill of head scratching- moments and genuinely good ones. But in the end, it’s a forgettable retread of a well-known origin story. The best thing that can be said is that it isn’t terrible. That doesn’t inspire hope for the remaining issues. For the same amount as this issue, readers can pick up a secondhand copy of Birthright or Secret Origin. Unlike Year One, those stories are at least memorable.

SUPERMAN: YEAR ONE #1 is Painfully Mediocre
1.5Overall Score

Alex SinclairDanny MikiFrank MillerJohn Romita Jr.Superman: Year One

Share On:
Tweet
Wizard World Philadelphia 2019
Review: Sabrina The Teenage Witch #3 Is A Spell Of An Issue

About The Author

Daniel Gehen
Editor-in-Chief

Dan was introduced to the 1960s Batman show at a young age, which developed into a lifelong passion for comics. When he's not grinding out his day job, he can be found reading about Scarlet Speedsters, Web-Heads, or Sagas just about anywhere. If it's good he'll read it. If it's bad... there's a chance he still might read it.

Related Posts

  • The Full Run: Final Crisis #6

    Daniel Gehen, Jason Jeffords Jr.
    July 2, 2020
  • What Looks Good for the Week of 8/21/2019

    Daniel Gehen, Jason Jeffords Jr.
    August 19, 2019

Support Us!

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Friends of the Site

  • SOLRAD
  • Your Chicken Enemy
  • Psycho Drive-In
  • Women Write About Comics
  • The Beat
  • Loser City
RSSTwitterFacebookgoogleplusinstagramtumblr

Comics Bulletin is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, audible.com, and any other website that may be affiliated with Amazon Service LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, Comics Bulletin earns from qualifying purchases.

All content on this site (c) 2018 The Respective Copyright Holders