Comics Bulletin logo
Search
  • Columns
    Random
    • Inside Out

      Kyle Garret
      September 15, 2003
      It's BobRo the Answer Man!
    Recent
    • Revisiting the Witchblade/Fathom/Tomb Raider Crossover

      Daniel Gehen
      February 8, 2021
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 2

      Daniel Gehen
      December 4, 2020
    • The Full Run: Usagi Yojimbo – The Wanderer’s Road Part 1

      Daniel Gehen
      October 30, 2020
    • What Looks Good
    • Comics Bulletin Soapbox
    • The Full Run
    • Leading Question
    • Top 10
    • The Long-Form
    • Jumping On
    • Comics in Color
    • Slouches Towards Comics
  • Big Two
    Random
    • Crisis #11 First Timers' Review: Punching the Soul

      Kyle Garret
      August 25, 2015
      DC Comics
    Recent
    • 3.0

      Review: X-MEN LEGENDS #1 Delivers A Dose of Nostalgia

      Daniel Gehen
      February 22, 2021
    • 4.5

      DCeased: Dead Planet #7 Presents a Hopeful Future (Review)

      Daniel Gehen
      January 22, 2021
    • Retro Review: Detective Comics #826 Remains a Holiday Classic

      Daniel Gehen
      December 3, 2020
    • DC Comics
    • Big Two Reviews
    • Marvel Comics
  • Indie
    Random
    • This Week in Boom!: Mermaids!!

      Kyle Garret
      September 16, 2015
      Boom! Studios, Indie, News, This Week in BOOM!
    Recent
    • 4.0

      Review: Beast Wars #2 another chance to change the past

      Stephen Cook
      March 3, 2021
    • 4.5

      Review: THE LAST RONIN #2 Hurts So Good

      Daniel Gehen
      February 19, 2021
    • TIME BEFORE TIME—A HIGH STAKES TIME TRAVEL SCIENCE FICTION SERIES SET TO LAUNCH THIS MAY

      Daniel Gehen
      February 19, 2021
    • Reviews
    • Archie Comics
    • Boom! Studios
    • Dark Horse
    • IDW
    • Image
    • Oni Press
    • Valiant
  • Reviews
    Random
    • 3.5

      ADVANCE REVIEW: The Vault #1

      Kyle Garret
      July 26, 2011
      Reviews
    Recent
    • 3.0

      Review: X-MEN LEGENDS #1 Delivers A Dose of Nostalgia

      Daniel Gehen
      February 22, 2021
    • 4.5

      Review: THE LAST RONIN #2 Hurts So Good

      Daniel Gehen
      February 19, 2021
    • 2.3

      Review: SAVAGE #1 Needs Taming

      Daniel Gehen
      February 16, 2021
    • Singles Going Steady
    • Slugfest
    • Manga
      • Reviews
    • Small Press
      • Reviews
      • ICYMI
      • Tiny Pages Made of Ashes
  • Interviews
    Random
    • Adam Warren: Making Comics Is Really Unhealthy

      Kyle Garret
      April 12, 2012
      Interviews
    Recent
    • Interview: Jon Davis-Hunt Talks SHADOWMAN

      Daniel Gehen
      June 8, 2020
    • Interview: Becky Cloonan talks DARK AGNES and Her Personal Influences

      Mike Nickells
      March 4, 2020
    • Simon Roy

      Interview: Simon Roy on His Inspirations and Collaborations on PROTECTOR

      Mike Nickells
      January 29, 2020
    • Audio Interview
    • Video Interview
  • Classic Comics
    Random
    • Classic Interview: Steve Skeates Pt. II - "A Kaiser with Poppy Seeds I believe it was"

      Kyle Garret
      August 21, 2015
      Classic Interviews, Interviews
    Recent
    • Countdown to the King: Marvel’s Godzilla

      Daniel Gehen
      May 29, 2019
    • Honoring A Legend: Fantagraphics To Resurrect Tomi Ungerer Classics

      Daniel Gehen
      February 15, 2019
    • Reliving the Craziest Decade in Comics History: An interview with Jason Sacks

      Mark Stack
      January 2, 2019
    • Classic Comics Cavalcade
    • Classic Interviews
  • News
    Random
    • Kickstrter Spotlight: Welcome to Denver A Mature Reader Graphic Novel

      Kyle Garret
      March 11, 2014
      Kickstarter Spotlight, News
    Recent
    • TIME BEFORE TIME—A HIGH STAKES TIME TRAVEL SCIENCE FICTION SERIES SET TO LAUNCH THIS MAY

      Daniel Gehen
      February 19, 2021
    • Image Comics and TMP Announces SPAWN’S UNIVERSE

      Daniel Gehen
      February 18, 2021
    • SAVAGE DRAGON IS A FORCE TO BE RECKONED WITH THIS MAY

      Daniel Gehen
      February 17, 2021
    • Press Release
    • Kickstarter Spotlight
  • Books
    Random
    • Review: 'The Best We Could Do' is a Moving Memoir and Corrective to Trump-era Xenophobia

      Kyle Garret
      February 13, 2017
      Books, Reviews
    Recent
    • Collecting Profile: Disney Frozen

      CB Staff
      November 22, 2019
    • Collecting Profile: NFL Superpro

      CB Staff
      August 31, 2019
    • “THE BEST OF WITZEND” is a Wonderful Celebration of Artistic Freedom

      Daniel Gehen
      September 15, 2018
    • Review: ‘Machete Squad’ is a Disappointing Afghan Memoir

      Jason Sacks
      July 31, 2018
    • Review: ‘Out of Nothing’ is the Antidote to Our Sick Times

      Jason Sacks
      July 23, 2018
    • Review: ‘Bizarre Romance’ Shows Rough Edges in the Early Days of a New Marriage

      Jason Sacks
      July 10, 2018
What's New
  • Review: Beast Wars #2 another chance to change the past
  • Collecting Profile: Blue Beetle
  • Review: X-MEN LEGENDS #1 Delivers A Dose of Nostalgia
  • Collecting Profile: Kraven the Hunter
  • Review: THE LAST RONIN #2 Hurts So Good
  • TIME BEFORE TIME—A HIGH STAKES TIME TRAVEL SCIENCE FICTION SERIES SET TO LAUNCH THIS MAY
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Contact Us
  • Write for us!
  • Visit Video Game Break!
Home
Big Two
DC Comics

Does Character Matter?

Kyle Garret
October 28, 2014
DC Comics, Marvel Comics, Slouches Towards Comics

“Superhero X wouldn’t do that!”

It’s a debate that’s been around since the first character was written by someone other than his or her creator.  Dialog changes, behavior changes, and some fans begin to question the validity of the recent portrayal of their favorite character.  Eventually we hear the phrase “that’s out of character.”  It’s a criticism steeped in the long history of corporately owned, episodic superhero comics, comics which have been published regularly for 50 or more years.  While it’s not always a legitimate complaint, it does happen, which begs the question: Does it matter?  Or, perhaps more importantly: Should it matter?

The impetus behind this column is Batgirl #35, but before I get to that, I should talk about one of the more defining character reversals we’ve seen from a superhero in decades: the Man of Steel movie.

I know people who are hardcore comic book fans who really enjoyed Man of Steel.  I am baffled by that.  My opinion ranges closer to Mark Waid’s, although he neverRocket mentions the giant plot holes which drove me batty.

But I don’t understand people who consider themselves comic book fans also claiming they liked Man of Steel — because that wasn’t a movie about Superman.  Even if you ignore the fact that (SPOILERS) Superman kills Zod (and how do you ignore that?), there’s the simple fact that he spends no time at all trying to protect the people who are being killed left and right by this giant fight he’s having with other super people.

That’s not Superman.  That’s not who Superman is.  It’s out of character.

But if comic book fans were able to enjoy the movie, does that, then, mean that character doesn’t matter?  This was the movie version of Kal-El, not the comic book one.  So do we just pretend that this is the Superman we get on the big screen?  And is he still Superman?

Or is this the result of having wandered through the desert for so long, so desperate for a glass of “Superman movie” that anything will quench our thirst?

The announcement of the new creative team and new direction for Batgirl built expectations up beyond belief.  Here was a new creative team taking an established character in a new direction, a direction that appeared to be substantially different than what we’ve seen from the rest of DC’s line of superhero comics.  Batgirl #35 looked like it was going to be fun.  It was going to be bright and energetic and it would appeal to more people.  The cover alone was enough to get people excited (justifiably so).

The reviews for Batgirl #35 haven’t been as universally positive as you would have thought given the build up, but it does appear to be getting more love than dislike.  Our own Chase Magnett has a nice review up, and I think he covers a lot of what I didn’t like about the comic (although I disagree with him on the point about the random dude at the beginning).  Chase’s review comes in a vacuum, though, as he addresses the storytelling on its own.  And I think that’s a valid and insightful approach and I think, when looked at that way, the story falters.

But, in my mind,  there’s another problem: it’s not a Batgirl story.

A lot of what Batgirl #35 got right is on display in Juliet Kahn’s review on Comics Alliance.  I’ll get into that in a minute, but first I want to pull this quote, which is actually a quote that Kahn uses in her review.  It’s from The Supergirls: Fashion, Feminism, Fantasy, and the History of Comic Book Heroines by Mike Madrid: “Batgirl is a female Batman can actually regard as a brilliant peer and a partner in the war on crime, the same way he would a male.”

Kahn goes on to point out that this aspect is put on full display in the best Batgirl stories, which, unfortunately, is the problem, because by that definition Batgirl #35 is nothing at all like the best Batgirl stories.

I understand that this is a bold, new era for Barbara Gordon.  I can relate to cutting loose after a big life change, so the fact that she got hammered and made out with random dude actually makes perfect sense to me.  But she’s still supposed to be Barbara Gordon and Batgirl.  In many ways, she’s always been the smartest member of the Bat Family.  She’s always seemed to be the most thoughtful, the one who considers all the angles, but with less distance than Batman.

Barbara Gordon doesn’t leave her laptop out to get stolen.

It might seem like I’m picking nits here, but it’s even worse if you consider that we’re still supposed to believe that this is the woman who used to be Oracle.  Oracle doesn’t leave her technology out for anyone to take.

Barbara Gordon doesn’t hide her Batgirl things at Black Canary’s, let alone hide them there without telling her.  Because she’s Batgirl, not Spider-man: she IS Batman’s equal.  She doesn’t do stupid things.

I have no doubt that much of the enthusiasm for this new version of Batgirl comes from a genuine enjoyment of the story.  I would also hazard a guess that a good deal of enthusiasm also comes from the simple fact that so many superhero fans have been wandering the depressing desert of the New 52, only to finally find the oasis that is Batgirl #35.  There’s water there, yes, but I think there’s been some fracking somewhere close by.

Finances are hard.

Finances are hard.

But either I’m way off base (and god knows it’s happened before), or there are a lot of people out there who have no problems reading a Batgirl comic that features a character who isn’t really Barbara Gordon.

Or is she?

I suppose that’s where the dilemma lies.  This is just a new interpretation of Barbara Gordon, so it’s still her, right?  Superman in the Man of Steel was just what a modern day version of the character looks like, yes?  Thor says “ass” now and the Vision talks about diarrhea.  These things are all “in character,” because the creators are always changing and it’s the stories that matter.

But, you know, if I’m buying a Wolverine comic to read about Wolverine then I want the Logan in that comic to actually be Logan, not some dude who just looks like him.  If I’ve spent any amount of time reading about a character, if I’ve become even a little invested, then I want that character to be, at his or her core, the same no matter who the creative team is.

Superman protects the innocent.  He doesn’t look the other way when people are dying around him.

Batgirl is the smartest person in the room no matter where she is, and I don’t mean book smart.  She thinks things through, at least enough to balance her checkbook (which she is apparently unable to manage these days).

Character matters.  The Marvel age of comics didn’t create a revolution because Spider-man was strong or the Human Torch was good looking.  It created a revolution because Peter Parker was like us and Johnny Storm was a guy we knew and Ben Grimm is how he made us feel.  We love Superman because he’s aspirational.  We love Batman because we’ve all felt powerless, and he took that power back.

Character matters because we grew up with these people.  We love the characters even more than we love the costumes, because costumes change, but the characters stay the same.

Or at least they should.

Would Batgirl #35 have been better had it featured a Barbara Gordon who resembled the one Gail Simone had written for the three years previous, the one who’d been portrayed in comics for 50 years?  Who knows?  It would have been a much different story, one I’m disappointed we didn’t see.

In some alternate reality, Superman saves the planet by actually saving people.  He floats up into the sky and the people cheer and yell their thanks, and as he goes off to fight the bad guy, the people he saved hurry off to help others, because they’ve been inspired by the Man of Steel.

That’s the movie I wanted to see.

That’s the story I want to read.

Because character matters.

DCMarvelOpinion

Share On:
Tweet
Singles Going Steady 10/28/2014: Orange is the New…
Planetary #7: Time To Be Someone Else

About The Author

Kyle Garret

EIC of Comics Bulletin, author of "I Pray Hardest When I'm Being Shot At," contributor to "Best New Writing 2014" and "Joss Whedon: Complete Companion," shopper of multiple YA books

Related Posts

  • Collecting Profile: Blue Beetle

    nguyen ly
    February 27, 2021
  • Collecting Profile: Kraven the Hunter

    nguyen ly
    February 20, 2021

2 Responses

  1. Sean R Reid October 31, 2014

    Here here!!

    This touches on some of what I was referencing in my Canon Fodder article. Arthur, in spite of the regional differences, always embodied the same character. He was never NOT all the things that made Arthur Pendragon unique and special. He was a king, a hero, and a national icon, even if the nation telling the story changed.

    The same should apply to Superman. You can change many things about Superman, but if you change his character then he ceases to be Superman.

  2. Tony Thompson November 1, 2014

    Superman protects the innocent. He doesn’t look the other way when people are dying around him.

    Given the religious symbolism in Superman- as a ‘savior’- it’s even more noticeable that he didn’t save the people around him during the battles in Smallville and Metropolis (except Lois). Ok, sure, he saved the planet, but it was endangered in the first place thanks to him. I’m also still bothered by the fact that he let Jonathan Kent die.

    As for Batgirl, well, I’m still boycotting DC Comics as a result of the reboot (I don’t see this ending any time soon, barring the return of the post Crisis universe in some permanent fashion), but I’ve read several pages from issue 35 and they seemed light and fun and a complete break from everything before. Now, I’m sure that was the point, but…
    Even though I’ve not read any Batgirl stories in the new 52, I’m very well acquainted with Babs and the world she inhabits (I miss Gail Simone’s BoP), and the character in issue 35 doesn’t seem like Barbara Gordon at all. The world doesn’t feel like Gotham either. It’s such a massive tonal shift that I’m having a hard time imagining it’s in the DCU at all. Perhaps it’s the Batgirl of Earth-Shazam, where things are more lighthearted (yeah, I know there were no Bat character on that world). Can you imagine Batgirl interacting with any of the Bat characters?

Support Us!

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com

Friends of the Site

  • SOLRAD
  • Your Chicken Enemy
  • Psycho Drive-In
  • Women Write About Comics
  • The Beat
  • Loser City
RSSTwitterFacebookgoogleplusinstagramtumblr

Comics Bulletin is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for website owners to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, audible.com, and any other website that may be affiliated with Amazon Service LLC Associates Program. As an Amazon Associate, Comics Bulletin earns from qualifying purchases.

All content on this site (c) 2018 The Respective Copyright Holders