Current Reviews


X-Men: Fairy Tales #1

Posted: Monday, May 22, 2006
By: Diana Kingston

Writer: C.B. Cebulski
Artist: Sana Takeda

Publisher: Marvel Comics

Hmm. I honestly don't know what to make of this one.

The inspiration for this, at least according to Marvel, is "Kitty's Fairy Tale", an old issue of Claremont's Uncanny X-Men. In that story, Kitty Pryde spins a fairy tale for Illyana Rasputin, with versions of the X-Men as the main characters (Xavier as a wise old wizard, Storm as a genie, Cyclops as a prince under a curse and so on).

Twenty-something years later (and for no apparent reason that I can see), Marvel issues a four-part miniseries retelling classic folk tales such as "The Tortoise and the Eagle", except with thinly disguised X-Men. Which kind of misses the point, because "Kitty's Fairy Tale" wasn't a direct adaptation of any specific story - the idea was to create a "new" fairy tale around the pre-existing character dynamics, rather than shoehorn the mutants into a narrative that's older than they are. So when she portrayed Nightcrawler as an adorable little girl-hungry plush toy, it was funny.

That's not what's happening here. This issue adapts the Japanese tale of Momotaro the Peach Boy, except it's Cyclops with a peach pit in one eye, and you can guess what happens when it's removed. When a nice bald man asks for help, Hitome/Cyclops goes off on a quest to gather some animal friends (a blonde bird, a blue-haired ape and a dog that can control ice) and defeat a master demon who likes to wear red and purple.

I suppose it's somewhat amusing to play "Find The X-Man" with the analogues; can you spot Mystique in the second scene? The problem is that the adaptations don't add anything to the story. The characters in this issue look like the X-Men, and have the X-Men's powers, but there's no other correlation: Angel is afraid to fly? Iceman has trust issues? Magneto's nasty just for the hell of it? Well... so what? The plot retains the simple structure of a folk tale - lessons are learned, the good are rewarded, the evil are punished - so it's not like Cebulski is making some grand metatextual statement here.

X-Men: Fairy Tales does what it says on the tin, so I can't fault Marvel for false advertising. But the results aren't very inspiring either. If I want to read the story of Momotaro, I can just look it up; beyond the questionable merits of retelling some popular legends, this miniseries doesn't seem to offer much more.

What did you think of this book?
Have your say at the Line of Fire Forum!